Presidential Election of 1876: Significance, Issues & Summary

  • Lesson
  • Quiz
  • Like?
Taught by

David Lobb

The election of 1876 was one of the closest races in American history. It tested the Constitution and resulted in a compromise that ended Reconstruction in America. In this lesson, develop an understanding of the election of 1876 and test your knowledge with a short quiz.

We also recommend watching Presidential Election of 1912: Candidates, Platforms & Significance and The End of Reconstruction and the Election of 1876

The Election of 1876

Despite allegations of corruption and scandal that swirled around Ulysses S. Grant at the end of his second term, he was eager to run again in 1876. However, scandal and the two-term tradition stopped him from moving forward with his desires. James G. Blaine of Maine emerged as the front-runner of Grant's Republican Party. But like Grant and many of the other Republicans associated with his administration, scandal tainted Blaine as well. At the Republican convention that year, the party put its hopes in the Ohio native Rutherford B. Hayes. Three times elected as the governor of Ohio, he had made a name for himself as a civil service reformer. His greatest strength, however, was that he did not offend the radicals or the reformers.

In St. Louis at the Democratic convention, there was little debate about who would be put forward as candidate for president. Samuel Tilden, the millionaire, corporate lawyer and reform-minded governor of New York, would be the choice. Tilden gained notoriety when he went after the infamous ring of Boss Tweed that controlled New York City politics through bribes and graft.

hays and tilden

The campaign of 1876 generated no burning issues. The main issues of the day centered around how to reconstruct and administer the South as well as reforming civil service work. Both Hays and Tilden favored conservative rule in the American South, and both favored civil service reform.

With little of substance to focus on, each camp turned to mudslinging. The Democrats aired the Republican's dirty laundry, reminding voters of the scandals and corruption present during the Grant years. In response, the Republicans linked the Democratic Party with secession and with the outrages committed against black and white Republicans in the South. Some Republican leaders went so far as to comment that every man who tried to rip the country apart was a Democrat and reminded the public that Abraham Lincoln's assassin was a Democrat.

Too Close to Call

Early election returns showed Tilden would score a victory. In most of the country, Tilden had an edge of just over a quarter million in the popular vote and 184 electoral votes by most estimates, just one shy of a majority. In some southern states the outcome was uncertain. Fraud and intimidation on both sides made accurate returns doubtful. In fact, three southern states - Louisiana, Florida, and South Carolina - sent in disputed returns. The Constitution offered no guidance on how to deal with this situation. Even if the procedure of the day empowered Congress to sort out the disputed votes, the Democratic House and the Republican Senate wouldn't have been able to reach a final agreement.

Unlock Content Over 8,500 lessons in all major subjects

Get FREE access for 5 days,
just create an account.

Start a FREE trial

No obligation, cancel anytime.

Want to learn more?

Select a subject to preview related courses:

Start your free trial to take this quiz
As a premium member, you can take this quiz and also access over 8,500 fun and engaging lessons in math, English, science, history, and more. Get access today with a FREE trial!
Free 5-day trial
It only takes a minute to get started. You can cancel at any time.
Already registered? Login here for access.


  • History Courses
  • Supplemental Lessons
  • Popular Articles

Search Our Courses

Did you like this?
Yes No

Thanks for your feedback!

What didn't you like?

What didn't you like?

Education Portal Video Lessons

The smarter way to study Short videos, Real results
  • More affordable than tutoring
  • All major high school and college subjects
  • Unlimited access to all 8,500+ video Lessons
  • Study on your own schedule
Try it Free